| Pope John Winners in NJSIAA Championships | ||||||
| Cross-Country Group Championships | Outdoor Sectional Championships | |||||
| Individual Champions | 100m | |||||
| Justin Scheid '04 | 15:53.11 | 2003 (A) | Greg Moore '10 | 11.1 | 2010 (A) | |
| Justin Scheid '04 | 16:15.94 | 2002 (B) | ||||
| Matt Day '98 | 16:25.2 | 1997 (A) | 800m | |||
| Mike LaLonde '96 | 16:58.4 | 1995 (B) | Charles DaSilva ' 19 | 1:55.79 | 2019 (A) | |
| Jon Buck '15 | 1:56.39 | 2015 (A) | ||||
| Team Championships | Trevor Potts '18 | 1:58.75 | 2018 (A) | |||
| Parochial B | 30 | 1995 | ||||
| Parochial B | 43 | 1994 | 1600m | |||
| Parochial B | 50 | 1993 | Chris Hatler '13 | 4:15.49 | 2013 (A) | |
| Indoor Group Group Championships | Pole Vault | |||||
| Christian Lavorgna '11 | 13-6 | 2010 (A) | ||||
| 55m | ||||||
| Joseph Rozynski '25 | 6.52 | 2025 (B) | Discus | |||
| Cole Farrand '11 | 169-5 | 2011 (A) | ||||
| 800m | Cole Farrand '11 | 160-1 | 2010 (A) | |||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 1:58.20 | 2005 (2) | Tim Schanstra '14 | 135-0 | 2012 (A) | |
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 1:58.99 | 2006 (2) | ||||
| Javelin | ||||||
| 1600m | Tim Schanstra '14 | 171-2 | 2014 (A) | |||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 4:20.92 | 2006 (2) | Charlie Hatler '15 | 167-7 | 2015 (A) | |
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 4:21.26 | 2005 (2) | ||||
| Justin Scheid '04 | 4:28.32 | 2004 (2) | 1600m Relay | |||
| Jon Juleus '08 | 4:28.89 | 2007 (1) | Sam Darrell '18 | 3:26.24 | 2018 (A) | |
| Charles Dasilva '19 | ||||||
| 3200m | John Novak '18 | |||||
| Justin Scheid '04 | 9:27.56 | 2004 (2) | Trevor Potts '18 | |||
| Justin Scheid '04 | 9:33.99 | 2003 (2) | ||||
| Matt Zappile '99 | 10:08.57 | 1999 (1) | 3200m Relay | |||
| Kevin Good '13 | 8:09.74 | 2013 (A) | ||||
| High Jump | Steve Skydel '15 | |||||
| Chris Thomas '07 | 6-6 | 2008 (A) | Sean Cobo '14 | |||
| Spencer Prudenti '27 | 6-0 | 2025 (B) | Jon Buck '15 | |||
| Chris Thomas '07 | 6-0 | 2007 (1) | ||||
| James O'Brien '17 | 8:13.43 | 2015 (A) | ||||
| 1600m Relay | Tom Perretta '17 | |||||
| Kyle Johnson '09 | 3:27.92 | 2009 (A) | Brian Warsh '16 | |||
| Kyle Nelson '09 | Chris Drace '15 | |||||
| Greg Moore '10 | ||||||
| Dylan Hurley '11 | Robert Russo '18 | 8:15.95 | 2018 (A) | |||
| James Setlock '20 | ||||||
| Steve Kulsar '04 | 3:34.02 | 2004 (2) | Charles Dasilva '19 | |||
| Chris Seabold '04 | Trevor Potts '18 | |||||
| Rob DeVasto '04 | ||||||
| Michael Carhart '04 | Outdoor Group Championships | |||||
| Team Championships | 100m | |||||
| Group 2 | 47 | 2004 | Mike Johnston '93 | 11.50 | 1992 (A) | |
| Group 1 | 28 | 2007 | ||||
| 200m | ||||||
| NJSIAA Indoor Relay Championships | George Peterson '01 | 21.9 | 2001 (A) | |||
| Mike Johnston '93 | 22.9 | 1992 (B) | ||||
| 800m Relay | Tim Bennett '90 | 23.30 | 1990 (B) | |||
| Greg Moore '10 | 1:33.18 | 2010 (NP) | ||||
| Dylan Hurley '11 | 400m | |||||
| Jamaal Knight '10 | Michael Carhart '04 | 48.53 | 2004 (A) | |||
| Jon Hilgart '10 | George Peterson '01 | 49.11 | 2001 (A) | |||
| Mike Guerrini '87 | 49.8 | 1987 (B) | ||||
| Raul Green '13 | 1:34.94 | 2013 (A) | Joe Doncheski '84 | 51.5 | 1984 (B) | |
| Ryan Beebe '13 | ||||||
| Lucas Steele '13 | 800m | |||||
| Jon Reilly '13 | Jon Buck '15 | 1:56.08 | 2015 (A) | |||
| Steve Caprio '03 | 1:36.97 | 2003 (2) | 1600m | |||
| Rob DeVasto '04 | Justin Scheid '04 | 4:16.57 | 2004 (A) | |||
| Chris Seabold '04 | Jon Juleus '08 | 4:16.71 | 2008 (A) | |||
| Mike Carhart '04 | Justin Scheid '04 | 4:18.80 | 2003 (A) | |||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 4:20.85 | 2005 (A) | ||||
| 1600m Relay | Anthony LaMastro '06 | 4:22.02 | 2006 (A) | |||
| Chris Fanelli '05 | 3:35.99 | 2004 (2) | ||||
| Chris Seabold '04 | 3200m | |||||
| Rob DeVasto '04 | Justin Scheid '04 | 9:10.35 | 2003 (A) | |||
| Mike Carhart '04 | Justin Scheid '04 | 9:11.09 | 2004 (A) | |||
| 3200m Relay | 400m Hurdles | |||||
| Clay Smith '07 | 8:23.56 | 2007 (1) | Caine Johnson '89 | 57.2 | 1987 (B) | |
| Robert Lennon '07 | Caine Johnson '89 | 58.24 | 1988 (B) | |||
| Jon Juleus '08 | ||||||
| Jeremy Scheid '07 | Long Jump | |||||
| Michael Lynch '90 | 21-3 | 1990 (B) | ||||
| Sprint Medley Relay | ||||||
| Bryan Downing '05 | 3:41.26 | 2005 (2) | High Jump | |||
| Dan Allen '06 | Matt Wines '91 | 6-3.25 | 1991 (B) | |||
| Jason Harper '06 | Chris Thomas '08 | 6-2 | 2007 (A) | |||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | Michael Lynch '90 | 5-10 | 1988 (B) | |||
| Raul Green '13 | 3:41.54 | 2013 (A) | Pole Vault | |||
| Ryan Beebe '13 | Christian Lavorgna '11 | 14-0 | 2011 (A) | |||
| Lucas Steele '13 | Eric Speck '90 | 12-0 | 1988 (B) | |||
| Chris Hatler '13 | Bob Leach '94 | 11-0 | 1993 (B) | |||
| Distance Medley Relay | Shot Put | |||||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 10:49.29 | 2003 (2) | Cole Farrand '11 | 57-3 | 2011 (A) | |
| Chris Fanelli '05 | ||||||
| Mark Peterson '03 | Discus | |||||
| Justin Scheid '04 | Cole Farrand '11 | 168-8 | 2011 (A) | |||
| Ricky Okoye '09 | 153-9 | 2009 (A) | ||||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 10:53.43 | 2004 (2) | ||||
| Steve Kulsar '04 | Javelin | |||||
| Kevin O'Brien '04 | Nick Vannatta '25 | 191-7 | 2024 (A) | |||
| Justin Scheid '04 | Frank Sullivan '89 | 162-5 | 1988 (B) | |||
| Pole Vault Relay | 1600m Relay | |||||
| Seamus Corcoran '28 | 20-6 | 2025 (B) | Jamaal Knight '10 | 3:20.26 | 2010 (A) | |
| Luke Gialanella '27 | Christian Lavorgna '11 | |||||
| Greg Moore '10 | ||||||
| Team Championships | Dylan Hurley '11 | |||||
| Group 2 | 38 | 2004 | ||||
| Chris Seabold '04 | 3:25.56 | 2001 (A) | ||||
| Adam Winfield '01 | ||||||
| Joe Luscik '01 | ||||||
| George Peterson '01 | ||||||
| Team Championships | ||||||
| Parochial B | 69 | 1993 | ||||
| Parochial B | 65 | 1994 | ||||
| Parochial B | 51 | 1990 | ||||
| Parochial B | 38 | 1991 | ||||
| Outdoor Meet of Champions | ||||||
| 1600m | ||||||
| Anthony LaMastro '06 | 4:13.02 | 2006 | ||||
| Javelin | ||||||
| Nick Vannatta '25 | 201-11 | 2024 | ||||